Author: Ken Akamatsu
Genre: Manga, Romantic Comedy
Publisher: Tokyopop
Cost: $9.99
Rating: ** (2 out of 4)
Availability:Widely Available
There’s nothing all that original about Akamatsu’s Love Hina, when you think about it. Sure, the storyline features a geeky guy in a house full of gorgeous women, but that describes almost all of the romantic comedy mangas to come to America from the land of the rising sun.
Keitaro Urashima is our hapless, dimwitted geek of a hero. It seems that our friend Kei made a promise to his childhood sweetheart that they would meet again one day at Tokyo University. The idea that if two people who love each other attend Tokyo University together, they’ll live happily ever after. Or study engineering. The book isn’t quite clear on that point.
Years later, Kei takes the entrance exam for Tokyo U – and fails. Miserably. Rather than settle for another school and disappoint his long-lost sweetheart (whose name, even, is lost to his memory [get the feeling this guy is yutzier than your typical yutz? I do.]), Kei opts to become a “ronin”. No, not a warrior for hire. This isn’t Lone Wolf and Cub. He becomes a college prep student, attending special classes to get him ready to pass the entrance exam.
Then he fails the exam a second time.
This is all explained in the first two pages, by the way. There’s still plenty more plot to go around. Or maybe not, come to think of it.
Kei has been kicked out of the house by his parents, and seeks refuge at his grandmother’s hotel, the “fabulous Hinata House!” When he arrives there, his grandmother is nowhere to be seen. Like any decent family member, he decides to take a bath. This leads to a difficult-to-describe misadventure with a naked woman walking into the bath.
It appears that when the hotel started to lose business, Granny converted it to a girls’ dorm – neglecting to mention this fact to her family. Especially to her virginal ronin grandson.
Through a turn of events that could only happen in a manga (or in its anime adaptation), Kei becomes the landlord of the dorm – in charge of the living conditions for five beautiful young women. And, of course, being the only male in the house, two of them promptly try to seduce him(!). Then we get a nice 183 pages of the usual sex-farce screw-ups and romantic comedy blow-ups, including a nicely-telegraphed notion that one of the women – Naru – is actually the girl that Kei made that promise to, long ago. By the end of the first volume, Naru and Kei are probably the only two people involved in the story (character or reader) who don’t see it coming a mile away.
Part of the problem with Love Hina is that Kei is not really somebody we want to see succeed. There’s the fact that he’s an out-and-out yutz. I don’t know about you, but I feel that there’s a certain level of schlemiel that justifies mercy killing. Especially in entertainment. The book at times can feel like an extended version of the torturous Mary Tyler Moore party episodes, as Kei gets involved in one embarrassing misunderstanding after another – and gets to see every single girl in the house naked at one point or another.
There’s also the fact that Kei develops an unwilling crush on Shinobu, a 12-year-old resident of Hinata House. Yes, 12. That’s as in 10 – 11 – 13… figure out what’s missing. This is a lesson in how to kill most readers’ sympathies quickly. Not many readers are quite ready to accept pedophilia as a harmless trait in a main character. Not many of the ones who aren’t named Humbert, anyway. While Kei is troubled by his attratction to Shinobu, he isn’t anywhere near as troubled as his Western audience will be. Even with the idea that this attraction is going nowhere, it adds a creepy edge to the romantic comedy that detracts from the humor of it all.
So, let’s see. Competent artwork and some funny stuff, accompanied by an unoriginal storyline, an unsympathetic main character, and a disturbing undertone all add up to a book that you might enjoy reading – but there are better things out there. Much better.
Before I forget to mention it, I should tell you that this book is part of the “100% Authentic Manga” line from Tokyopop. That’s translated manga that’s printed in its original order – right to left. Don’t worry. You get used to it. Just don’t try to read Moby Dick the same way. There’s a mistake you don’t make twice.