How exactly do you manage to alienate your readers in just one simple state?
Follow up a perfectly heartfelt message about violence against women with an article on pornography.
Of course, if ABC News’ PrimeTime Thursday can do it, I guess that I can, too.
You might notice that the webpage for PrimeTime’s story is entitled “Love on a Porn Set.” How very Harlequin of them. Of course, the story that the show told was something completely different.
Diane Sawyer plastered on her “concerned matriarch” face and whispered questions to young porn stars between shots of sleazy producers and surgically-enhanced bimbos. In particular, she followed the story of Michelle, whose fans know her as “Belladonna.” Michelle entered the porn industry two years ago, and that’s when PrimeTime started following her story.
Consider this for a second. PrimeTime not only produced a story on the porn industry, they worked on it for two solid years at least.
There were many things wrong with PrimeTime’s report. There’s the fact that it was a ratings grab disguised as investigative journalism. There’s the fact that it exploited the young women just as much as the pornographers did. And there’s the creepy enough fact that Diane Sawyer’s “feminist” act in fact hid a much more conservative – and mercenary – agenda.
“I warn you,” Sawyer said as heavily-blurred porn footage plays, “these images are not easy to watch.”
Tell that to the people who have made the porn industry one of the biggest industries in America.
Sawyer commented several times on the fact that porn had become “disturbingly mainstream,” showing images such as a young couple who won a contest to be on-set for an actual porn shoot.
Pornography, however, is a genre that flirts constantly with the mainstream. Consider the success of 70’s films such as Deep Throat. And in recent years we’ve seen porn stars finally get into Playboy, we’ve seen them host specials on the E! Entertainment Network, we’ve heard them on the radio, seen them in mainstream films (playing themselves) – we’ve even seen an off-off Broadway musical based on Debbie Does Dallas1.
And when it comes down to making porn mainstream, even PrimeTime gets their shot. Everybody who ever watched E! in the late 90’s has at least a passing familiarity with Jenna Jameson – but PrimeTime just gave us Belladonna, complete with clips from her films and a selected filmography – and a good amount of air time.
And what about that air time? Quite a bit of it was filled with censored clips from porn flicks – all so that you could see just how deviant and degrading it was, of course. Not because ABC wanted to show porn clips on a news show.
At this point, I would like to say – I feel that arguing the morality of the existence of porn is rather a moot point. It exists, and chances are that it always will exist. And as long as there’s money to be made from it, there will always be more of it. I do feel that the vast majority of it is degrading, and I feel that the industry is in need of regulation – not to control content so much as to control the way the studio treats its stars. Beyond that, the best regulation is this – if it offends you, don’t buy it.
And this point was made by PrimeTime a couple of times. At one time, Diane Sawyer cited the fact that in Nevada, prostitution in brothels is legal and regulated – and that the brothels are legally required to use condoms as they conduct business. Something that has yet to hit most of the porn industry. In addition, porn stars are paid a flat fee by the sex scene with no royalties – meaning a star can be paid $1000 for what will make the company millions.
And as for Diane Sawyer….
As for Diane Sawyer….
Diane Sawyer picked up a bucket of glue and tacked the edges of her mouth down into one of the most dour faces I have ever seen. She did not allow herself any expression but one of deep, deep concern throughout the show.
“Do you feel that age limit is all right?” she asks one porn producer. “Eighteen years old?” The answer doesn’t play.
“I tried calling Time Warner,” she says, “and Comcast…” All in the quest to confront major Fortune 500 companies that hold stock in porn companies. She reminds us that “hotels make millions” by selling adult films to their rooms, and that that makes them just as involved in this corruption of the innocent as the slick, slimy producers who casually work porn into discussions with would-be models.
“I don’t understand,” she says to Belladonna, “how you can tell these horrible stories and still be smiling.”
And Belladonna – like a good shill – breaks down into tears. Right on cue. “I like to hide,” she sobs.
As does Diane Sawyer. Sawyer wanders from point to point – the lack of medical care for porn stars, the exploitation of those stars by their producers, the big corporations making money off of porn – but she never stays on target. Why?
Because Sawyer knows how to exploit, too.
Sawyer knows that a good interviewer can get their subject to cry. And she knows that you can argue your point without ever having to actually state it. By talking about medical care, age limits, and exploitation, Sawyer builds a mask for herself as a “good feminist.” But in the end, the point of the PrimeTime report boils down to, “These people get filmed having sex. Isn’t it dirty and wrong? Why do people buy it?” And that message is not feminist – it is ultimately conservative.
Far be it for me to defend the porn industry. It is, after all, an industry built on exploitation. Many people have filmed adult movies only to regret it afterward, and many people have been mistreated in the industry.
But the only real difference between the porn industry and ABC News is that the porn industry, at least, is up-front about exploitation. “Here,” they say. “Here’s a scantily-clad woman signing autographs at a booth.” From start to finish, pornography is what it is – and does not try to disguise itself.
But ABC feels free to disguise conservative moralism and an exploitative ratings grab as “investigative journalism.” And when it comes down to it, that’s an even worse exploitation. Because the people being exploited are not just Belladonna and Diane Sawyer. They’re the audience sitting at home.
And tell me, how does it feel for the PrimeTime producers and sponsors to realize that they’ve just gotten their little share of the porn market, too?