And this comes out of my recent trawling to find comments that I missed.
I appreciate feedback – both positive and negative – on the entries I post. However, it’s a lot of work to trawl through my archives to find a new comment like the following comment from my entry on Dennis Miller’s Tonight Show appearance (“The Nazi Stuff”). Notice that the entry was posted on February 26, and the comment posted on March 5 – well after the entry had dropped out of sight from the front page.
Gotta love an art fag, always wanting to say some retarded statement, whilst clueless on world issues…go read resoloution 1441, Iraq has had 17 opportunties to disarm and has violated every single one. Stick to freeform paint splattering fruitcake.
Posted by: Picaso on March 5, 2003 04:10 PM
Glad to see that free and open, intelligent discourse is alive and well. I particularly like the use of “fag” and “retarded” as epithets, combined with the use of the archaic “whilst”. Not to mention the usual statement that I should shut up because I’m “clueless” on world issues. I would refer “Picaso” to resolution 242 which clearly calls for Israel to withdraw its soldiers from the occupied territories. And compared to Iraq’s “17 opportunities,” Israel has had amazing opportunities to comply with its own U.N. resolutions. However, our diplomatic position has been to pursue change through peacable means and through the United Nations. And it still is.
And I don’t do freeform paint splattering. Let alone on or with fruitcake.
And for a moment, allow me to address the issue of “not knowing” enough to comment on current events. It’s the latest in a barrage of “shut up” tactics employed on the peace movement. It’s appeared in public forums, on cable channels, in comments, and in many fine weblogs.
Honestly, if we start requiring people to know everything about anything before they speak, we’ll have an entire nation of mutes. When it comes to the sciences, nobody knows enough to say they know everything – and when it comes to the human side of everything, there’s no possible way to know everything. Gore Vidal puts it best in Burr when he states that there is no “truth” of a story, there’s only “my version” and “the other version”.
Before you make the accusation that people protesting for peace (or, for that matter, pulling for war) “don’t know what they’re talking about,” please consider that they may know just as much – or even more – than you do. If you watch CNN’s 24-hour coverage of the war, the chances are pretty good that you are not well-informed. If you only watch Free Speech Television’s progressive coverage of the peace movement, the chances are pretty good that you are not well-informed. If you’re obsessed with Fox News Channel’s “fair and balanced” coverage, it’s very likely that you are not well-informed. If you only listen to Rush Limbaugh, Don Imus, Michael Moore, or any number of inflammatory political pundits, it’s very, very likely that you are not well-informed. In fact, if you have every possible news source linked directly into your brain so that you are constantly downloading information on current events and constantly updated with the latest reports, it’s still very likely that you are not well-informed.
It’s no fault of the media (well, okay. It’s mostly the fault of the media), it’s part of being human. We hear the news, filter out what works, and cram the rest into the garbage disposal. And the news itself is not always accurate, either. And what do we do when the reports on the same subject provide completely different points? We extract information and synthesize opinions as part of the miracle of the human mind.
To say that somebody should shut up because they don’t have all of the information is patently ridiculous and logically flawed, particularly if the one calling on somebody to shut up has no idea of what the speaker in question actually knows. And you can’t find out what the speaker knows if your idea of engaging them in conversation is to call them names and tell them to shut up, then refuse to listen to anything else that they have to say.