Read this entry aloud for comical effect = pay me mah moneys
Via Boing Boing comes this link to Joho the Blog’s “20 Things I’ve Stolen.”
The idea is simple. Under the “if value, then right” argument, if something can be shown to have value, then the creator of that object has the right to demand compensation for its use. This is used to justify some of the more heinous acts of companies like the RIAA or MPAA – the idea being that if you rip a CD or DVD to put on your iPod, then you have recognized further value than was initially included in your original purchase, and the creator (or the MPAA/RIAA, since the creators don’t usually see a dime in those cases) has the right to demand that you pay them for that further value.
Joho’s got 20 things he then confesses to “stealing” under this argument – including a Ding-Dong (by saving half for later snacking instead of consuming it all at once) and the lyrics to a song (by saying “What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been” without using air quotes).
I’ve made a list of ten things I’ve done that violate the “if value, then right” argument – can you think of at least ten that you’ve done?
- I have used a porcelain piggy bank to hold down papers on breezy days in addition to using it to hold change.
- I have used a hammer to knock errant objects other than nails into their proper place.
- I have used a pocket knife not only for cutting, but also to clean under my fingernails.
- Conversely, when found without a pocket knife, I have used fingernail trimmers to cut yarn and small threads.
- To get a near-perfect circle while working on a design project in college, I placed the base of an Arizona Iced Coffee bottle on the paper and traced around it – using the container as a makeshift stencil.
- Additionally, I refilled said container with water after the iced coffee was gone, and later gave it to a friend who needed a similarly-shaped bottle for a play she was staging.
- On many occasions as a child, I placed a sock not on my foot but rather on my hand, tucking some of the material between my thumb and forefinger to fashion a crude puppet.
- My bookends have not only propped up books, but also DVD’s, CD’s, and – on a couple of occasions – my door.
- I have purposefully purchased items not only for the goods themselves, but also for the many uses I knew I could put their container to.
- The bag I carry my still camera and its accessories in is, in fact, an old bag for a long-lost Kodak Super-8 film camera.
Saturday, August 9th, 2008